LFGB vs DGCCRF for Nylon Kitchenware: A Comparative Analysis & DGCCRF Compliance Guidelines

LFGB vs DGCCRF for Nylon Kitchenware: A Comparative Analysis & DGCCRF Compliance Guidelines

Both LFGB and DGCCRF are based on the EU Regulation EC 1935/2004. However, Germany’s LFGB places stringent emphasis on organoleptic properties and specific hazardous substances (e.g., aromatic amines, PAHs), while France’s DGCCRF prioritizes compliance with permitted substance lists, metal migration (nickel/chromium), and French-language conformity documentation. For nylon kitchenware to meet DGCCRF requirements, targeted formulation adjustments and testing processes are mandatory for your manufacturer to deliver products that pass French regulatory checks.

Core Differences (Key for Nylon Kitchenware)

|Comparison Dimension|German LFGB|French DGCCRF|Implications for Nylon Kitchenware|

|Regulatory Basis|§30-31 of Germany’s Food and Feed Code (LFGB), aligned with EU framework and specific regulations (e.g., EU 10/2011)|EU 1935/2004 + French DGCCRF 2004-64, Décret 92-631, with more detailed control provisions|Compliance with both EU-wide and French national requirements is mandatory; LFGB certification alone is insufficient|

|Organoleptic Testing|Extremely strict, focusing on odor/taste migration via a definitive three-point comparison method with clear threshold values|Mandatory testing applies, with greater focus on market supervision random inspections; conformity statements must include formal organoleptic evaluation records|Comprehensive organoleptic test records must be retained for inclusion in DGCCRF conformity documentation|

|Migration Testing|Overall migration + specific migration, with focus on heavy metals (Pb/Cd), PAAs, PAHs, etc.|Overall migration + specific migration, with stricter limits for BPA, phthalates, and an additional Dynamic Migration Test (DMT); extra testing required if recycled material content ≥25%|Additives in nylon (e.g., plasticizers) must meet French limit values; dedicated testing for products containing recycled materials is mandatory|

|Metal Migration|Primary focus on leaching of heavy metals (lead, cadmium)|Enhanced requirements for nickel and chromium release; separate testing for metal substrates and coatings|Nylon kitchenware with metal components requires additional nickel/chromium migration testing|

|Conformity Documentation|Acceptable in German or English; the cutlery mark is a commonly recognized certification logo| Mandatorily written in French; must include material lists, test reports, traceability information, and explicit reference to DGCCRF 2004-64|A dedicated French-language Declaration of Conformity (DoC) must be prepared|

|Material Control|Testing categorized by material type; separate requirements for plastics (PC, PVC, etc.)|Technical specifications for 23 material categories; vinyl chloride monomer testing for PVC, formaldehyde leaching testing for melamine|Nylon, as a plastic, must be tested in accordance with plastic category requirements under DGCCRF 2004-64|

Step-by-Step DGCCRF Compliance for Nylon Kitchenware

1. Clarify Material Lists & Compliance Basis

- Compile a full list of nylon raw material grades, additives (plasticizers, antioxidants, etc.), color masterbatches/dyes, and coating/printing components; confirm all substances are included in France’s permitted substance lists.

- Finalize applicable regulations: EU 1935/2004, EU 10/2011 (Plastics), DGCCRF 2004-64, and Décret 92-631.

2. Adjust Formulations & Production Controls

- Prohibit use of French restricted substances: e.g., specific phthalates, BPA, and hazardous dyes (containing primary aromatic amines); prioritize additives with official DGCCRF approval.

- Strictly control heavy metals: Lead, cadmium, nickel, and chromium content in raw materials and color masterbatches must meet migration limit values; avoid mixing with recycled materials (additional testing required if recycled materials are used).

- Production process: Control temperature, pressure, and cooling time to minimize monomer residues; establish robust batch traceability and retain raw material Certificates of Analysis (COA) and production records.

3. Conduct Targeted Testing & Documentation Preparation

- Mandatory testing items:

Overall migration (simulants selected based on food contact type: e.g., acetic acid, ethanol, olive oil; temperature/duration aligned with actual usage scenarios), specific migration (BPA, phthalates, heavy metals, formaldehyde, etc.), organoleptic testing, additive residue testing (e.g., vinyl chloride monomer for PVC components), and metal migration (nickel/chromium for products with metal parts).

- Select a qualified testing laboratory with official DGCCRF testing capabilities, and obtain test reports compliant with French standards (e.g., NF EN 1186).

- Declaration of Conformity (DoC): Drafted in French, including product information, regulatory compliance basis, test results, traceability details, and clear marking of DGCCRF 2004-64.

4. Upgrade In-Factory Quality Control

- Establish incoming raw material inspection: Verify COA for each batch, with a focus on hazardous substance content.

- Implement in-process patrol inspections: Monitor production parameters to prevent material degradation and the formation of new hazardous substances.

- Conduct finished product random sampling: Regularly submit samples for DGCCRF-compliant testing and retain all test reports.

- Document management: Assign a dedicated staff member to maintain French-language DoC, material lists, test reports, etc., to ensure full traceability.

Common Misconceptions & Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

1. Myth: LFGB compliance equals DGCCRF compliance

LFGB and DGCCRF differ in specific migration limits and documentation requirements—dedicated DGCCRF testing is non-negotiable.

2. Myth: Overall migration testing alone is sufficient

DGCCRF imposes additional strict limits for specific substances (BPA, phthalates, etc.)—all required specific migration tests must be completed.

3. Myth: English is acceptable for conformity documentation

DGCCRF mandates French-only documentation; non-compliant language may result in penalties from French market supervision authorities.

Summary

For nylon kitchenware to achieve DGCCRF compliance, compliance with the EU 1935/2004 framework is fundamental, with a focus on meeting French DGCCRF 2004-64 requirements for formulation limits, migration testing, and French-language documentation. Instruct your manufacturer to adjust formulations, upgrade quality control systems, conduct dedicated DGCCRF testing, and prepare fully compliant documentation in accordance with the above steps—this is the only way to ensure products meet the strict requirements of your French customers.

Hengyang Suan Houseware is a company who specialized in kitchenware manufacturer, we include different materials such as nylon, silicone, PP, TPR... We’re a solution maker and customization provider for overworld kitchenware brands. Feel free to contact us, we will give you a response within 24 hours.